Wind farms preferable to fracking

Independent, 14 May 2012:

The campaign against wind turbines seems to be gathering momentum with luminaries such as Donald Trump, the Duke of Edinburgh, and your own correspondent Terence Blacker in the vanguard (30 April). Add to that the anti-turbine campaign launched in Parliament by Lord Carlile on 19 April and the report by Bill Bryson (30 April), President of the Council for the Protection of Rural England (CPRE) and one has to wonder whether windmills should ever have been allowed into the UK.

What no one from the anti-turbine lobby seems to recognise is that without renewables we will be forced to develop shale gas. Fracking is a filthy process involving undeclared chemicals that will see thousands of well-heads spring up all over our green and pleasant land. There is likely to be permanent contamination of the countryside by toxic ponds and significant threats to animal and human health. Why on earth aren’t CPRE opposed to fracking instead of wind turbines?

Dr Robin Russell-Jones
Stoke Poges, Buckinghamshire





John Beveridge, QC chairs today’s session.

Mr Patrick Holden (CBE), Director of Sustainable Food Trust spoke on Climate Change and the Soil. 

Farmers, stock and their impacts on the land

Jonathan Scheele, Head of the EU Commission, UK asked What is Europe Doing?

Kyoto Protocol continues.  Outcome from Durban 2011.  Implementation and Negotatian Phases to see through.  eg negotiatons for a new legally binding international agreement are still not quite tight enough and must be continued.  Perhaps the goals are too soft.  Durban tried to make what was agreed in Cancun in 2010 implementable.  China in particular is trying really hard despite the huge number of power stations they have, to implement new measures.  Sources of funding need to be ensured up to 2020.  It is all quite long-term.

Dr Robin Russell-Jones, Help Rescue the Planet, presented: Climate Change and Newscorps.

Counter disinformation by repeating effective facts.  So many to choose from, where would you start?  Cliamte change deniers do have an effect on the public as they have very little to draw on so they repeat the little they have.  Corruption, greed and power are a powerful combination to overcome.   Dr Russell-Jones spoke of incorrect references to reporting in the media.  He referred to Lord Lawson, Matt Ridley and Christopher Booker and their roles in swaying public opinion.  He mentioned that a group of 6 doctors had written to the British Medical Journal and Lancet to state that as the links have inevitably been found between most diseases such as heart disease, lung cancer etc and their obvious causes over many years, now “transparency around climate change sceptics is essential”.

Discussion: How to get the word out?  Engage a well-known public figure to assist….


Walt Patterson of Chatham House spoke on Smart Energy.

Removing fuel from our supplies removes our flexibility in the short-term.   He mentioned an insurance company that offers insurance against a “flat home” as well as all of the usual contingencies.  The Green Deal is coming.  Customer and company both benefit.  The investment is tied to the property for existing and future owners.  Provision for of decentralised source for each household would be an option – eg heatpumps.  Governments should stop telling us what to do and start showing us.  If the energy transfoer is to happen all the key players need to see opportunities rather than threats.  The vision of a smart energy system must work for all.  if you have bought a house that is cheaply made but poorly-insulated, the only outcome is expensive long-term running costs.

Kent Walwin, Film Director “We’re Going to Make a Film”

Could the issue be turned into something the general public could respond and react to?  Visual media is a primary method to learn about the world.  Many movies have depicted global tragedy (Outbreak, The Day After Tomorrow, 28 Days Later and Nostradamus – one of Kent’s films).  There are usually 2 reasons the world might end.

These are bad luck such as the deep impact of a meteor or the spread of a virus, or due to humanity’s own egocentric overuse of the planet (global warming, pollution, overpopulation, genetic engineering) such as Waterworld, An Inconvenient Truth.

The common factor is that all movies suffer from our belief in our own salvation.  The heroes of the film usually survive.  What kind of film could we make to Help Rescue The Planet?

John Mills, Environmental Health Officer, Why I Joined Help Rescue the Planet.

He outlined the role of Environmental Health Officers from dealing with noise pollution to infectious diseases to other public health issues.  Climate change is closely linked to our health and well-being.  Here is a list of issues faced: houses, air-quality, regulating industrial facilities, assessing carbon emissions, infectious diseases, food and water shortages (eg predicted that global warming will mena that 10,000 extra cases of food poisioning may occur a year from food prepared within private homes),  water-associated diseases, Legionnaire’s from air-conditioning, water contaminated by sewage/animals, increase in soil disturbance, increase in breeding grounds for disease, rodent-borne disease increases, Australia predicts that 80 million people will be living in malarial areas by 2080, increase in tick diseases, plagues of fleas etc, allergies will increase (eg house dust mite), melanoma rates have significantly increased within the last decade.  There is a Saving Our Skins campaign in place to help Environmental Health Officers deal with Sun Protection.

Phoebe Mousley-Jones, A-Level Student and HRTP trustee, “What Does the Future Hold?”

Phoebe stated that young people are the catalysts of change as they are already inheriting the devastating consequences of choices by their parents and grandparents.  Problem – some young people are worried whilst others do not realise the impacts of climate change and that they are overdependent on the current resources.  She presented a cross-section of information from around the world noting that Africa and other third-world areas will likely be the first to suffer the effects and also outlined direct impacts locally.  She also mentioned a report in a UK paper that criticised initiatives encouraging people to insulate their homes and asked “how does that help?”.

Richard Gillies, of Marks and Spencer, Director of  “Plan A”

Plan A because there is no Plan B.  As carbon emission reductions will not be enough to counter the rising effects of increased population for food and water, Marks and Spencer has responded by implementing their own environmental measures.  In 2007, the world’s population used one-third more resources than the plant can renew.  M & S has taken the initiative to ensure that what the customer sees in the shops (marketing & retail, consumers) is a reflection of what the customer doesn’t see (environmental responsibility in manufacturing, and use of raw materials).  Campaign to donate clothes back to the shop in exchange for vouchers.  The use of Joanna Lumley, Mylene Klass and a few others in their promo to encourage this.  The need for re-sorting of donated clothes has created new jobs and a relationship with Oxfam has resulted.  M&S has also successfully cut carbon emissions, reduced their plastic carrier bags by 80% (by introducing a charge to customers as a dis-incentive) and have green-sourced their electricity supplies.   All of this has happened in just 5 years.

Gary McKeone of St George’s House, Windsor Castle.  How To Organise a Climate Change Consultation.


John Beveridge, Friday’s Chair stated that science will ultimately yield evidence and reason.  In the meantime a herd instinct will apply to people.  Climate change involves emotions and value judgements.  Media reports include extreme assertions on each side.  We must rely on truth of cause or confusion will hold sway over debate.  More education is needed.  He also noted that the success of the week was owed to the determination and commitment of Dr Robin Russell-Jones.

Dr Robin Russell-Jones presented his closing remarks: Methane is locked in the tundra of the Arctic and is at lethal levels.  The straitjacket that is the combusion engine.  Two-thirds of energy is lost from a nuclear power station before it leaves the plant.  Challenges involve finding storage for power that is not in batteries eg air compression,  solar panels on churches, biomimicking, capturing carbon effectively, taxing energy rather than income, finding incentives for people to insulate their homes.  The most promising presentation of the week was the carbon capture process from Finland.

HRTP Chairman, Mike Clink presented his overview:

There is no more oil – is it good news or bad news?  The demand from developing countries lifestyles like ours.  Our families are a reflection of where things are at.  His 10 yr-old grandson is doing global warming project at school.  The desire to own a fast car is not realistic anymore. What have we learnt this week? He thanked all of the wonderful speakers for their contributions and noted that some are in a great position to join forces with Help Rescue the Planet.

The week concluded with a reception and Concert.  The performance by the Taplow Girls’ Choir was absolutely lovely.   One soloist in particular promises to be heading for great things in the future.


Climate Change Conference at RIBA, Day 4


Kent Walwin, Film Producer provided an interesting talk (pre-recorded) on The Sierra Leone Project. 

Craig Bellamy, football player, set up a football academy  in a village in Sierra Leone.  Context was post-war, infrastructure was ruined and electricity inconsistent.  Solar panels, and compressed air for electricity storage used to help achieve self-sufficiency for the village.  Palm oil also used to make diesel when necessary.

Carl Bennett of Intelligent Utilities presented The Green Deal – Are You In or Out?

He comes from a banking and mortgages background and now works towards energy and money-saving products.  A tiny percentage of UK residents buy green products despite savings often being available.  Green is difficult to sell.  Cost and consumer awareness vs perceived benefit.  Carl mentioned the Utility Refund company which finds refunds for customers who have been overcharged by their power supplier.  Once they have a refund they are more receptive to other ideas to save their money.

Comments included: “we are energy inefficient because heat is not highly valued”.  If you could capture your heat waste and re-use it or  sell it on there would be a lot in it for everyone  – Peter Prior

“The way we use electricity since its original invention with the coil is very inefficient”  Roy Baria.

Local generation of electricity has huge advantages over big remote power plants as they would be less vulnerable to attack or disruption.  – Dr Robin Russell-Jones.

 The Green Deal

Environmental policy (awaiting governmental backing) to have households fitted with energy-saving technology.  Once consumers get past the idea of their new energy plan ie paying off the energy saving device there will be flow-on effects.  Tradesmen will be able to register themselves and become accredited under the Green Deal.  This plan is under construction with a large amount of private funding available and awaiting government input.  For those who do not take part, incentives by the government and council may be imposed as financial penalties.

Peter Prior of Summerleaze spoke about Anaerobic Digestion and Beyond.

He has a scheme for digestors in schools for food waste.  It is feasible to be able to deal with sewarage waste.  Comments included: the Government is always ready to shoot you in the foot or tax you if you have a good idea.  Government ministers should not be solely responsible for picking the viability of projects because too many do not get the opportunity.  There is so little time and complex legislation to get through.  Simplicity of legislation would be beneficial more great ideas could flourish and less time would be wated.  More jobs would be created.

Dr Robin Russell-Jones went retrospective and summarised his 40 Point Action Plan from 1991 to outline which initiatives that he suggested to the government have actually been addressed.

How to flourish within a regulatory framework? 1991 was the time of John Major.    Thatcher followed and she was slightly more receptive during the so-called “Golden Age of Environmental Campaigning”.    The 40 point plan review found that hardly any of the intiatives have actually been carried out effectively.


Rob Moore, Director of Behaviour Change, spoke How to Create Consumer Demand for the Green Deal? 

Perceptions include – the deal is overfamiliar and not very interesting.  Assumption that schemes will be more of the same.  It is just rebranding.  Perception that subsidies will only apply for the elderly.  The risk of it being hard to understand since so many parties would be involved.  Can create a lack of trust.

For success it requires clarity, simplicity, consistency, honesty, transparency and government backing.  At this stage, all sectors involved cannot yet promote it effectively whilst the public lacks awareness of the scheme.

Professor Paul Ekins, Energy and Environmental Policy from UCL asked: Is The Government Doing Enough?

The government has a certain amount they need to do due to EU obligations.  20/20/20 by 2020 Programme.  The commitment is to a framework of:

– cut 20% in carbon emissions

– 20% renewable energy

– 20% reduction in energy use below what it otherwise would have been.

The Climate Change Act was passed in 2008.  It contains ambitious targets to reduce emissions, binding carbon targets and a clear accountability framework.

Prof. Ekins said he thought the government was doing well.  The decision of whether to invest in new gas supplies remains.  Carbon capture of gas emissions is still not proven.  Nuclear power and coal stations (built in 1970’s, 1980’s and 1990’s) will be closing over the next 10 years.

Kye Gbangbola, Director of Total Eco Management Ltd asked How Does the Global Reporting Initiative Work? 

Leadership in Climate Change using the Global Reporting Initiative to address the biggest challenge of our times.  Preparing a sustainibility report is difficult for some businesses so they should seek assistance.  The Climage Change Act 2008 has provisions to make reporting mandatory for all businesses.    The benefits include reducing costs, increasing profits, retaining staff, staying competitive, reducing environmental impacts, Meet 21st century challenge with 21st century solutions.  A 3-D appproach to using resources should be used in which production, distrubition and consumption should always result in the extraction or recycling of worthwhile resources from the waste products.  One interesting point is that the Olympic Stadium has the ability to be deconstruted later and reused.  It weighs less than the stadium built in Beijing.